All playbooks
    Winning the business

    Choosing and defending auction versus private treaty

    The vendor has a strong view about method that may not suit the property or the market.

    Do this now — in this order

    1. 1Match method to buyer depth, not to office preference.
    2. 2Be honest about what auction does when enquiry is thin.
    3. 3Explain the role of a price guide and the risk of guide creep.
    4. 4Set the reserve conversation date at the start of the campaign.
    5. 5Explain what a pass-in actually costs in momentum and perception.
    6. 6Give the vendor the decision with consequences attached to each path.

    What to say

    Method honesty

    "Auction works when we have competition. If we don't create it, the auction becomes a public deadline that hands buyers leverage. Here's how I'd decide by week three."

    Why it works

    Method is a strategy decision, not a branding decision. Agents lose credibility when the method serves the office rather than the property.